SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
But then what about the salah, the actions i dont care, about the way we pray salah,
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
but was this not revealed along side the Quran.
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
I am just being a rationalist here,
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
coz once we argue on these points, i know theyare many of our muslim brothers who would punch me for this.
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
Did he act on his own desire,
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
probably yes but did Allaah know about this yes ofcourse Allaah did know.
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
But why, was the Prophet corrected what could be the reason,
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
secondly this is the same argument, the Muslims put across, if the Prophet was corrected in the Quran on these 2 occassions, then even it is the same for the sahih hadith because if he was wrong Allaah would correct him.
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
Morevoer, i am looking at things from a POV.
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
To brother AB personal question, if a non-muslim friend helps u a lot a dear lot, but is against Allaah and Prophet, what could be your reaction, as i am facing the same situation now.
|
SlaveofAllaah wrote:
|
Secondly can anyone tell me did the HOLLAND pm comment that if Prophets was born in dutch, the pm would kick him out.
Thirdly is the danish cartoons guy dead. Yes or no. The above 3 questions, anyone can volunteer to answer.
|
Never heard of the above
Take care bro and sorry for the late reply
- Wed 07 Mar, 2007 5:40 am
Post subject: Re: He did not talk of his own desires
Thanks as usual, next Insha Allaah once I have time, i will quote few hadith, which i have to believe dearly, as I dont have enough evidence to counter them.
Insha Allaah in other thread, few hadith, which dont really make sense to me. Well i will put it here as I am lazy as usual.
1) The chair of Allaah shook when, one of the sahabas was martyred as reported in sahih hadith. I have to believe it, and rest is left to Allaah, as I am trying hard not to believe in religion blindly accept for what is mentioned by Allaah.
2) Sahih bukhari last hadith explicitly mentioning Prophet, could read and write. Well, i feel over a period of time either the hadith is corrupted or not interpreted as this is illogical.
Well, i can vividly remember this hadith at present. But, i repeat again I believe in this though it is does not make any logical sense to me. But as usual Allaah knows the best. I personally believe do have iman and belive in One God and the messenger.
I always ponder we fight over the hadith, there is an ayat in the Noble Quran the Word of Allaah and it say when there is a financial transaction between any 2 of them, there should a 3rd as a witness and should be documented.
I wonder, and again wonder how many muslims follow this dearly. What i know for sure is the Whites follow it by letter .
All times are GMT + 10 Hours
Powered by phpBB 2.0 .0.17 © 2001
phpBB
Group